June 07, 2007

Shingu, secret of something-or-other

Didn't I see this thing in Magic Users Club?

That time it got transformed into a building-size stuffed bear. Haven't seen yet what happens to it this time.

The box says the title of this series is "Shingu: Secret of the Stellar Wars". But the title splash is translated as "Muryou: Record of the School Wars". Just as long as it isn't "Record of the Lodoss wars", I figure I'll be OK.

UPDATE: That has got to be the worst OP I have ever watched. Blech!

UPDATE: 9 minutes into the first episode and I already like what I'm seeing. The art style is a bit idiosyncratic, but there's a nice dry sense of humor hiding in the shadows. After the above alien ship gets defeated by something else equally mysterious, there's eventually a televised announcement by the PM.

Our hero, his sister, and his mom watch the PM's announcement on TV. He bows to the camera, and the kids bow back to the TV. I almost fell out of my chair laughing. It was a very small touch, but a very good one.

UPDATE: It depends on how it's handled, but if it's handled well then a series benefits from the presence of a smartass imouto. This one's got one. Hajime's bratty kid sister is named Futaba. After they have dinner, Futaba politely serves tea to her mother. Hajime says, "What's the point of acting sweet and cute to Mom?"

"She gives me allowance money," Futaba responds. It's nice to see a 9 year old who understands the realities of life.

UPDATE: Yet another thing that's rapidly making me a fan of this series: the primary characters are in middle school, but all of the male parts are voiced by male seiyuus.

UPDATE: And at the end of the first episode, two characters fire energy blasts at each other. I am definitely hooked.

Muryou reminds me a bit of Toga from Gravion, except that I'm quite certain that he isn't anything like as naive or maladjusted. I wonder what it's going to take to get that smile off his face?

UPDATE: And the ED sucks, too. Still, it looks like this is going to be good.

UPDATE: Lame OP and ED notwithstanding, after two episodes I'm even more hooked. The third episode is titled "The name is Shingu", so now I get to find out what that means.

UPDATE: As of the end of episode 3: they're rolling out the plot pretty fast. I wonder if it's going to stall? Sometimes in a series like this they set up a situation and then tell day-in-the-life stories for a long time before finally finishing the basic story -- if they do finish it. I think they will in this case, but I prefer a series where there's continuous progress in the overall story.

That is one of many things that Petite Princess Yucie did well. Virtually every episode contributed at least a little to the overall plotline, either by introducing new characters, causing continuity changes relating to existing ones, or by introducing elements of the backstory. I hope this series does the same, but if they continue at the breakneck speed I've seen so far they're going to exhaust themselves. And me.

I'm getting more hooked by the moment. Oh, and they do reveal what Shingu means, but I'm not going to say.

UPDATE: Episode 4, and yet more points. A class in English, and the voice actor for the teacher was American, not Japanese. It was background for a voiceover; they didn't need to do it. A hundred other English classes I've seen in anime and they always use a Japanese voice actor who doesn't really quite speak English. Not this time.

There's an attention to detail here, an understanding of the fine points. I'm very impressed.

And an incidental character from the first episode shows up again and may not be incidental after all.

UPDATE below the fold:

Don't want to overload the front page with images, so this one goes here:

This turns out to be one of the most interesting characters in the series. Her name is Nayuta and she's a study in confused motivations. I expect great things from her before the series is over.

The series is staying relatively upbeat. Naturally, there's got to be some romance, but no angst so far.

UPDATE: End of episode 4, and it's beginning to be difficult to write about specifics without revealing spoilers. I will say this: the story doesn't feel like it's stalling, and though there have been several twists and turns I didn't predict, I also get the feeling of a strong hand on the tiller.

I'm happily confused about what's going on but it's clear that the writers are not -- and that is a good thing.

Posted by: Steven Den Beste in at 05:29 PM | Comments (13) | Add Comment
Post contains 807 words, total size 5 kb.

1 Just as long as it isn't "Record of the Lodoss wars", I figure I'll be OK

One of my favorites.  I even bought the soundtrack (though I wish I could find the English versions of some of the songs on CD).  You pick on it so!  But there are 'grim and gritty' aspects to it, true enough.

I'm enjoying your Shingu posts.  Perhaps if Comcast deigns to put them up again I'll try to pick up where I left off (which is not much further than you've already watched).

Rich

Posted by: Rich Jordan at June 07, 2007 09:41 PM (0lxAh)

2 Anime reviews are always fun, though there is the dilemma present for good series:  read the reviews in detail and figure out what he's talking about, or avoid spoilers in case you watch the series later.

In the case of Divergence Eve/Misaki Chronicles, I've done the later, since it sounds interesting enough to be worth tracking down.

Posted by: metaphysician at June 08, 2007 04:26 AM (Od3fy)

3 The original Lodoss OVA was pretty good for its time, and the soundtrack is superb.

Sadly, everything that came after the OVA was utter crap.

Posted by: Pixy Misa at June 08, 2007 08:39 AM (PiXy!)

4 I must've watched the crap that Pixy refers to. It was a reenactment of a D&D game, boring in the extreme.

Posted by: Pete Zaitcev at June 08, 2007 02:06 PM (9imyF)

5 There's a Lodoss War TV series (crap) and a sequel called Legend of Crystania (triple crap with extra crap).

It's possible that you did see the OVA, if it was boring but had good music, since it really is a re-enactment of a D&D game.

Posted by: Pixy Misa at June 08, 2007 03:27 PM (PiXy!)

6 I've been told that "Louis the Rune Soldier" is also part of that series; it stunk, too.

Posted by: Steven Den Beste at June 08, 2007 03:38 PM (+rSRq)

7 I've seen both. I see no specific relationship between the two in terms of setting.  They do seem to be of the same genre: "Western swords & sorcery in animé"  Louis is a bit more generic though.  Lodoss was pretty good at the time for a fantasy fix, except for often crappy animation, melodrama, confused plotting, slow story, obvious tropes, two-dimensional villains, and tossing in characters just to have them there, etc. etc.

Dwarf? Check.
Elf girl?  Check.
Cleric?  Check.
Noble-but-Naive human warrior? Check.
Morally challenged thief, er, rogue? Check.

Elf girl likes the human warrior? Check.
Elf and dwarf argue constantly? Check.

Think of it as Tolkien, with approximately one-billionth of the backstory, plot, and story telling.

My theory is that Lodoss and Louis represent an exercise in "the grass is greener."   Animé may have its clichés and tropes, but we haven't spent years and years getting sick of them all like we have with American TV/Cinema.  It's different, and that helps make it seem fresh.  So when the Japanese look for something that's different to them, and start looking to our cultural tropes, it's simultaneously fresh to them and old to us.

But Loius as part of the Lodoss franchise?  Possible, but I don't buy it.  For one thing, they have absolutely no staff, studio, or anything else in common.  (Though I didn't check the TV series.)

Posted by: ubu roi at June 08, 2007 04:12 PM (tVZo7)

8 I balked at the suggestion of a Louie-Lodoss connection myself, but it turns out that <a href="http://www.animenewsnetwork.com/encyclopedia/people.php?id=2988">Ryo Mizuno</a> wrote the original story for both (the Lodoss novels and the Louie manga).

Posted by: Andrew F. at June 08, 2007 07:01 PM (YsROS)

9 Hmmm, guess the "hyperlink" button is there for a reason... Ryo Mizuno's ANN page.

Posted by: Andrew F. at June 08, 2007 07:06 PM (YsROS)

10 I've seen several claims that there are clear references in the Louie novels that place it on the same world as Lodoss. I wouldn't know what to look for, myself.

If the Lodoss Wikipedia entry is correct about its origins as a Dungeons and Dragons campaign, a whole lot of things about Louie's world make more sense...

-j

Posted by: J Greely at June 08, 2007 08:40 PM (2XtN5)

11 Easiest point of congruence is worship of the war god Mylee.

You know, I actually enjoyed Louie, but the ending was too open-ended. It's obviously intended to continue on, until we get King Louie or something similar, but the anime doesn't go there and doesn't really satisfy the way it ends either.

Posted by: Avatar at June 08, 2007 09:46 PM (s42Qj)

12 Groan.  Well, actually, I don't remember the gods' names from Lodoss.  I was going to pop one of the disks in to check but I couldn't find them in a brief search. (They're somewhere here....)  And it's not really worth a long one.

As for Louie, one of the things I said about it was that it wasn't half bad... until the last two minutes where they were obviously bidding for the next season.  They do both have that same feel of a poorly developed world, though I never really thought about it until now.

Posted by: ubu roi at June 08, 2007 10:05 PM (tVZo7)

13

Part of why I didn't like the ending was that it was stupid. There was a major, major logic fault in it. Let's see if the spoiler tag works in comments:

Now I'm sure that someone can try to come up with some sort of explanation for that, but don't bother. That wasn't the primary reason I disliked it. The simple fact that they weren't willing to wrap up the story was also a big problem, but even that wasn't it.

The biggest problem was that Ila didn't deserve what happened. After what she'd done, and clearly how she felt, the main four characters treated her as if she wasn't even there. "Bye! See you maybe never again! Have a nice life!"

Posted by: Steven Den Beste at June 08, 2007 10:10 PM (+rSRq)

Hide Comments | Add Comment

Enclose all spoilers in spoiler tags:
      [spoiler]your spoiler here[/spoiler]
Spoilers which are not properly tagged will be ruthlessly deleted on sight.
Also, I hate unsolicited suggestions and advice. (Even when you think you're being funny.)

At Chizumatic, we take pride in being incomplete, incorrect, inconsistent, and unfair. We do all of them deliberately.

How to put links in your comment

Comments are disabled. Post is locked.
17kb generated in CPU 0.0121, elapsed 0.0182 seconds.
21 queries taking 0.011 seconds, 30 records returned.
Powered by Minx 1.1.6c-pink.