April 23, 2009

Saki -- ep 1

I'm weak. My download site had the first two episodes of Saki so I just downloaded them. And I just watched the first one.

And you know what? It was really good!

Why? Because Saki isn't a wimp. She's a strong person, one who knows what she wants and doesn't get pushed around. She's also an awesome MahJong player, almost superhuman.

In the first episode she gets dragged to the MahJong club by Kyoutarou, her friend from middle school, who plays but isn't very good. She plays three games and ends up with a score of 0 each time -- which, it turns out, is damned near impossible. Yet she seemed able to do it. The president of the club notices this, and since the president had been looking over Saki's shoulder and had seen her hand at one point, she knew that Saki had thrown the game.

Nodoka, the gorgeous one who is also by far the top player in the club, ends up chasing Saki through the rain and begs her to keep playing, but Saki refuses.

Next day, the club president is handed an opportunity to get a favor from Saki, and the favor she asks is that Saki play two more games. In her fourth game at the club, the other players all are aware that Saki is trying to get a score of 0 and they actively work to make it difficult for her. Even Nodoka, who isn't really trying to win; she's trying as hard as she can to make it so that Saki's score is non-zero.

And Saki still does it.

Presumably ep 2, which I'm about to watch, is about two things: trying to convince Saki to join the club, and trying to convince her to try to win when she plays instead of scoring zero. Because if she has both the luck and skill to score zero, then she should really kick ass when she's trying for a high score. The president (Mako) is seeing championships in her future.

The fact that Saki isn't a wimp and isn't a klutz is what made this work for me, I think.

As to the yuri elements, well, yeah there's some of that. The first scene in the show is Saki outdoors during lunch, reading a book, and seeing Nodoka walking by -- and blushing because Nodoka is so gorgeous. And there's this:

/images/02516.jpg

It isn't what it looks like. Or rather, it's a tease. It's suggestive to the people who are looking for yuri elements, but it can also be read completely innocently. Nodoka just was running through the rain to catch up with Saki, and is out of breath. And she's not there to confess love or anything like that; she's there to beg Saki to play against her again. And Saki says "Atashi wa Mahjong suki janai n desu." I don't like Mahjong.

At least in the first episode, all the supposed yuri elements amount to double entendres, whether in words or actions or pictures. They're deliberate on the part of the director, but apparently not on the part of the characters.

But damn, that episode was fun to watch. And it's nice for a change to have Kugimiya Rie doing the voice of a character which is neither loli nor tsundere.

UPDATE: Ep 2, and as expected, at the end of it Saki joins the club. But it didn't come about the way I expected, and I rather liked the way it did come about.

Ep 2 tossed in an element that looks ripped off straight out of Angelic Layer. Which is not a good thing, but may be tolerable.

But for the most part it remains the case that I like what I see. And Saki is still not a wimp.

I don't understand this imagery:

/images/02517.jpg

/images/02518.jpg

The first is from the OP, and after Nodoka's transformation she's shown fighting against another magical girl.

The second is from ep 2. It's a vision Saki has; as if she can sense Nodoka's ki or something like that. Is there something supernatural going on in this series? Sure hope not. This, on the other hand:

/images/02519.jpg

Everyone likes dancing chibis, don't they? That's the ED. (J, this is for you.)

Posted by: Steven Den Beste in General Anime at 07:18 PM | Comments (14) | Add Comment
Post contains 711 words, total size 4 kb.

1 It doesn't hurt that the ED is amazingly cute.

As far as I'm concerned, this is the best season I've seen in years. And there's still at least two purportedly-good shows I haven't even tried yet!

Posted by: Avatar_exADV at April 23, 2009 07:32 PM (vGfoR)

2 Looks like Bamboo Blade was better.

Posted by: Pete Zaitcev at April 23, 2009 07:59 PM (/ppBw)

3

Looks like Bamboo Blade was better.

Perhaps so, and I'm looking forward to that one. But Funi hasn't even announced a release date for it yet, so it's going to be a long time coming.

Meanwhile, this is pretty darned good. Especially despite all the Gonzo nay-sayers; this looks like it has the potential to be a winner.

Posted by: Steven Den Beste at April 23, 2009 08:03 PM (+rSRq)

4 It does seem to be a surprisingly good show and has gotten better every episode.  Episode three further builds Saki and Nodoka's characters.

Posted by: Doyen at April 23, 2009 08:56 PM (GTo9u)

5 "Only as good as Bamboo Blade" is no insult.

 Is it supernatural? Naw. It's just Gonzo making the mahjongg element more interesting - girls moving tiles around all day isn't that visually compelling.

Posted by: Avatar_exADV at April 23, 2009 09:48 PM (vGfoR)

6 Huh.  Okay, it's somehow ended up on my disk drive too, so I'll have to give it a try later on.  (I'm a sucker for cute EDs.)

Posted by: Pixy Misa at April 23, 2009 09:53 PM (PiXy!)

7 I've played mahjong in Japan many times, and let me tell you, the scoring system would be a challenge for a PhD mathematician.  You can't just play to get the best hand--you have to consider how it will affect your score.  I lose all the time because of that.
I wonder how they'll handle that aspect of it without boring or confusing the viewer.

Posted by: Toren at April 23, 2009 09:55 PM (dVb3R)

8

It's been handled pretty well so far, because the scoring has been the key to the game. That's because Saki has been trying to manipulate her score to make it so the outcome is exactly zero, and to do that she can't just make the best hand available to her. Especially in her fourth game, where the other players were aware of what she was doing and were trying to foul her up, there was a lot of arcane scoring going on.

One way they handled that was by having Mako and Kyoutarou watching the game, and him being clueless so she had to explain to him what was happening. But they're using other tricks too, and were able to stuff a lot of info about scoring into the flow of things without making it dry.

It's actually quite well done.

Posted by: Steven Den Beste at April 23, 2009 10:02 PM (+rSRq)

9 The difficulty in scoring is that hands are worth a different amount based off of two different measures - the "minipoints" and the "fan", both of which scale on what kind of hand you have, various environmental variables, which way the wind is blowing (no, really), and whatnot.

Something just occurred to me... how the heck do you account for ura-dora if you're doing the plus/minus zero trick? (Er... there's a bonus tile that's determined by flipping a tile on the "dead wall" (tiles not used in the current round), and having that bonus tile in your hand means it's worth additional points. When you get a "kan" (four of the same tile), you reveal an additional "dora" bonus tile. But if you declare riichi (basically "I'm one tile away and I'm not doing anything but waiting for it"), and you win, you get to reveal additional dora tiles, one for each one already revealed - these are the "ura dora". Potential for a massive score bonus, but also difficult to avoid if you're thinking that way.)

Posted by: Avatar_exADV at April 23, 2009 10:35 PM (vGfoR)

10 Well from the 3rd series it looks like "fan service" to me and the occasional "She's got enormous....." Works for me. What I'd like to do is get into the guts of that automatic table. "Fascinating Captain."

Posted by: toadold at April 24, 2009 03:36 AM (zcbXo)

11

The scoring really throws me.  Before I watched the first episode, I actually read the Wikipedia article on mahjong.  It allowed me to recognize certain elements of the game -- but not the rice sticks, which I don't recall being mentioned.  The scoring and strategy though?  Not a clue what was going on.

There are a lot of elements I like about the show, but I don't like having a complete inability to understand the game and the aforementioned trauma to Saki.  With what was thought to be a totally crap season turning out to have some surprisingly strong shows, this one is on the bubble, but slipping off the back side.

Posted by: ubu at April 24, 2009 05:35 AM (i7ZAU)

12

What I figured out is that the scoring is zero-sum. The initial points the players start with amounts to table-stakes, and in order to win points someone else has to lose points.

That's why, in her family, Saki learned to always score 0. What she's doing is to break even so that she isn't giving away points to anyone else or taking points from anyone else. Because when she took points from someone else they'd get mad at her, and when she gave points away to someone else, then that helped them beat another person and that one would get mad at Saki. By breaking even, she can't be blamed for affecting the outcome of the game, which minimized the abuse.

Posted by: Steven Den Beste at April 24, 2009 09:31 AM (+rSRq)

13 Well, no, because that really IS impossible - you're going to lose points any time someone gets tsumo, and that's not avoidable unless you literally win every game (or deal into someone else's ron, in which case you lose even more points). It's not that each hand ends up at zero, but the sum total of each round.

I'm thinking that the tension in the family went deeper than who was scoring what in mahjongg, only that Saki was too young to figure it out (but everyone had to play if anyone was going to play mahjongg, because there's only four of them).

Posted by: Avatar_exADV at April 24, 2009 09:51 AM (vGfoR)

14 I watched the first ep but found it really dull, but then I don't have a clue about how mahjong works, and I find watching other people play sports about as fun as watching paint dry (is also why I found casion Royale dull- 49 minutes of Bond playing cards?)

Posted by: Andy Janes at April 24, 2009 10:17 AM (4DhfH)

Hide Comments | Add Comment

Enclose all spoilers in spoiler tags:
      [spoiler]your spoiler here[/spoiler]
Spoilers which are not properly tagged will be ruthlessly deleted on sight.
Also, I hate unsolicited suggestions and advice. (Even when you think you're being funny.)

At Chizumatic, we take pride in being incomplete, incorrect, inconsistent, and unfair. We do all of them deliberately.

How to put links in your comment

Comments are disabled. Post is locked.
17kb generated in CPU 0.0066, elapsed 0.0141 seconds.
21 queries taking 0.0088 seconds, 31 records returned.
Powered by Minx 1.1.6c-pink.