January 15, 2008
They finally sent me my regkey. I found it when I got up early this morning because of pain and insomnia, so as something to keep me entertained while waiting to get sleep enough to go back to bed, I tried using it.
First a cockpit error: the "free" and "pro" versions are different install files. Just putting the regkey into the directory, the way they say, doesn't unlock the DVD play abilities. You have to install the Pro version.
I confess I was a little fogged, so it took me a while to figure that out. Fortunately, I did figure it out before making an ass of myself with a post on their bulletin board, so it's a secret between you and me.
So you install the right download file, and put a DVD in the drive, and fire up Zoomplayer, and the DVD plays, right? Not so fast...
Nope, what Zoomplayer does is tell you that you have to configure DVD playback first. And boy, is it a joy.
The first thing you get to choose is how you're going to choose. Here's what you get told:
* Standard *
When the Standard method is enabled, Windows will try to build it's own Audio/Video decoding Graph. This is far from a good solution as Windows tends to mess up when multiple DVD Decoding filters are installed or if a specific Audio Renderer needs to be in use. I highly recommend staying clear of this option.* Smart *
This is the recommended playback method. When enabled, you can easily pick and choose the components used to playback the DVD with easy verification to make sure there are no missing components.* Manual DVDGraph Profile *
This method allows you to specify a Graph Profile which exactly describes which components are to be used for playback. Modification of such profiles may be a bit complex for the average user and are of no benefit over the Smart method.
OK. There are three buttons labeled "Standard", "Smart (Recommended)", and "Manual". Care to see what "Smart" brings up? Prepare to descend into Bedlam below the fold.
UPDATE: I can't figure out any way to fix the aspect ratio, and I can't figure out any way to get subtitles to display. None of the option menus or right-click choices make any difference at all.
Which means Zoomplayer is a really good tool for watching fansubs, and utterly useless for DVDs. Since it's DVD playback that you get when you pay, and fansub playback is totally enabled in the free version, there's no reason for anyone to send those guys money.
Under the assumption that they do like having people send them money, you'd think they'd put more care into making DVD playback work well, wouldn't you?

That's the "easy" way. What you see is the choices I finally ended up with that worked, sort of. The default choices didn't. I said "Yeah, go with the ones you've picked for me" and tried to run the DVD, and got a popup error telling me the sound filter wouldn't work. Which was peculiar because I wasn't using the sound filter they complained about.
Mucking around for about ten minutes, I finally ended up something that would work, but only just barely. Playback was at about one third rate.
Then I ended up with this. It almost works normally. Once a second the video stutters, but that's enough to make it completely useless for normal use. No way I'm going to put up with that.
I was using the first DVD of Magikano to test it. With the settings shown above, it was running about 45% usage of the CPU, with occasional spikes much higher than that. PowerDVD playing the exact same DVD never gets about 10% and usually runs about 5%.
That's 45% of a dual-core 2.4 GHz T7700 Core 2 Duo. In other words, it was nearly saturating one full CPU. Probably the reason for the stutters was that it couldn't keep up. But don't ask me why.
That was windowed, with a pretty small window.
Probably there's some "obvious" thing I could change here. Maybe bypassing DirectSound and sending the audio directly to the external Soundblaster box I'm using. Or maybe the problem is in configuration of the PowerDVD video decoder. For it to use that much CPU, it cannot be taking advantage of any hardware acceleration. But I can't see any way for me to control that; the only configuration choices I get for the Cyberlink video decoder are for color adjustment and deinterlacing.
It doesn't make any sense. Even a pure software decoder shouldn't require that many CPU cycles. What in hell is it doing?
Another problem is the DVD menus. When your mouse hovers over a hotspot, there is supposed to be an icon that magically appears. At least, that's what's always happened with every other DVD player I've ever used. But it doesn't with this one. You just have to click and hope.
Sorry, folks, I'm really unimpressed. About the only thing this would be good for is doing frame grabs, and if I want to do that I'm better off using Vidomi. Or VLC, bad as it is.
As to Zoomplayer, I just wasted $28.
UPDATE: Or so I was going to post. The stuttering playback was in a window, and for completeness I thought I should test it full screen, so that I could sneer about two-frame-per-second or some such.
So I just fired it up again -- and now playback is smooth, even full screen. CPU usage is comparable to PowerDVD.
What in the hell?
Even if it works, forcing a user to dive into that configuration screen is, ahem, "Not ready for prime time". I ended up with the choices I did by sheer experimentation, blindly stumbling around in the dark.
UPDATE: Hey, Zoomplayer? Where are my subtitles?
UPDATE: Oh, great. Trying to get subtitles to work, and this is the result:

Horseshit.
UPDATE: OK, that seems to have been caused by me changing the audio decoder from FFDShow to PowerDVD. Switching it back makes it work again. But I still don't have subtitles.
If I can't get subtitles to display, then this is utterly useless to me. I don't speak Japanese and I won't listen to dubs.
UPDATE: And they're botching the video aspect ratio.

This is a 4:3 title. The video area being used is 640*540, which isn't anything standard that I've ever heard of.
Display aspect ratio has its own set of multiple control frames in the configuration, but it's weird that it doesn't work without fiddling.
Posted by: Steven Den Beste in Computers at
10:28 AM
| No Comments
| Add Comment
Post contains 1109 words, total size 7 kb.
Enclose all spoilers in spoiler tags:
[spoiler]your spoiler here[/spoiler]
Spoilers which are not properly tagged will be ruthlessly deleted on sight.
Also, I hate unsolicited suggestions and advice. (Even when you think you're being funny.)
At Chizumatic, we take pride in being incomplete, incorrect, inconsistent, and unfair. We do all of them deliberately.
How to put links in your comment
Comments are disabled. Post is locked.18 queries taking 0.0169 seconds, 16 records returned.
Powered by Minx 1.1.6c-pink.