January 15, 2008

Zoomplayer Pro: Aspect Ratio

The thread structure of the previous thread is a mess, so I'm going to pick up with a new one.

More experimentation with trying to fix the aspect ratio, and I wondered what frame grabs did.

When the screen shows the 4:3 video as 640:540 (which is too tall) a frame grab gets stored as a 720*480 image, which contains a 640:480 image plus black bars on the sides. Which is peculiar. Why store 720 pixels when you know you're not going to use them? And if they can get the aspect ratio right for the frame grab, why not on the display?

UPDATE: Aha!

Zoom Player can display subtitles on top of the video when playing media files under the following conditions:

You must have DirectVobSub (VSFilter) installed on your system.

Query: so why isn't it automatically part of the installation, pray tell?

On the page for it:

DirectVobSub is a Subtitling component that integrates into Zoom Player, allowing it to display internal/external media file subtitles. This is an integral component and its installation is highly recommended.

Someone needs to look up "integral" in the dictionary. If it's integral, installation shouldn't be optional.

UPDATE: Two mirrors are given for the NT version. The first one gave me a broken file. The second one was complete. I installed it, letting it choose its own default directory.

Result? No difference. Zoomplayer still isn't showing me subtitles.

UPDATE: Turns out DirectVobSub is part of the "Install Center", so I already had it. Which is why installing it manually didn't help: it already didn't work.

I'm running the Install Center again and letting it install everything.

UPDATE: Aspect ratio problem fixed:

In the "Video" menu, one of the check boxes is "Prevent VMR Video Renderers from correcting Aspect Ratio (can fix image-resizing artifacts)"

I probably checked that one because I was thinking of the lousy resizing I saw when I was looking at fansubs. Unchecking it fixes the problem. Now the video size is 720*540, a nice clean 4:3.

But I still don't have subtitles. I'm going to try a full reboot, and a different DVD.

UPDATE: Here's a frame grab from "The 36th Chamber of Shaolin" and here's a frame grab from "The Matrix". But I can't get either of them to display subtitles, either.

I'm stumped. I'm beginning to wonder if this is yet another "minor incompatibility with Vista" issue, having to do with the VobSub library not loading because it can't be found.

Even with all other issues solved, if I can't display subtitles then this is useless to me.

UPDATE: I spent some time looking through their support forum and didn't find any help there. I did find that they're using Vista for their development, so it seems unlikely that this is a Vista incompatibility problem.

I'm out of ideas, and out of patience. Hell with it. For all its crustiness, at least PowerDVD actually works correctly.

Posted by: Steven Den Beste in Computers at 11:15 AM | Comments (5) | Add Comment
Post contains 492 words, total size 3 kb.

1 Well, i was going to say ZP looks like a player built by engineers for engineers... but arent' you an engineer?  Not good.

I guess I would have to specify audiovisual engineers.  Yeah, this thing gives the user too much control; anyone that doesn't know everything there is to know about filters, codecs, and the entire DVD-to-screen process is going to get into trouble.

I still haven't solved my weird problem either.

Posted by: ubu at January 15, 2008 04:07 PM (GAG5U)

2

Well, I used to be an engineer.

Zoomplayer demonstrates a common failing of software developed by hackers. When there's a configurable choice, there are three ways to cope with it:

1. Select a choice and hard wire it.
2. Select a choice, but make it possible for advanced users to change it.

Those are both correct answers, depending on the situation.

3. Force the user to make a choice.

This is invariably bad, but it's what Zoomplayer does far too much. When I got the pro version installed, and popped in a DVD, and tried to play it, I got told that I could not until after I configured DVD playback.

Wrong answer. The difference between #2 and #3 is that in #2 the program defaults to an acceptable choice, which I as a user only muck around with if I want to. Yeah, I'm an engineer, but I'm no expert on the details of audio and visual filters in the Windows environment -- and I don't want to be an expert in those things.

This was one of the big failings of Linux back in the day. Anyone could install Linux on their system, as long as they were willing to compile the kernel for their particular hardware. The most important thing the Linux community has done right in the last five years was to start getting away from that kind of thing.

Commercial DVD player programs get this right. If you install PowerDVD, start it running, and insert a DVD, you can play it with one mouse click -- on the "play" button. It will do everything right to make it play. That's how it should be.

Asking the user to configure the decoding chain is idiocy; it's geek madness. It's a dedication to free-as-in-beer run amok. It's a sign of someone who doesn't understand the paradox of choice (which is, too many choices is worse than no choices at all). Most users don't want to deal with that shit, and they shouldn't have to.

There should be a default set of choices that work, even if they don't work ideally. A user who isn't interested in knowing what an "FFDShow" is (and I still don't know, and don't want to) shouldn't have to find out.

The primary goal should have been one-click play. That's more important than anything else. Why in hell should I have to figure out which DirectDisplay mode to use? That's really stupid. Zoomplayer has a "basic configuration mode" and an "advanced configuration mode", but that one's part of the "basic configuration mode". It shouldn't have been.

Even the best fall into this trap sometimes. Microsoft has. It used to be that for a lot of programs, the first time you tried to access the online help, it would construct a database cross-referencing the help frame. And before it would start doing that, it would ask you to make a three-way choice of how involved the database would be: fast and stupid, slower and more comprehensive, a lot slower and even more comprehensive. No user should have had to do that, and Microsoft eventually wised up and that doesn't happen any more.

Posted by: Steven Den Beste at January 15, 2008 05:35 PM (+rSRq)

3 I call it the Law of Sensible Defaults.  Even before I configure the widget, it should do what the average user would expect.

Now, ZoomPlayer has some stupid defaults.  The cursor keys, space bar, mouse buttons and scroll wheel are all set by default to do things no-one would ever want to do.  It's easy enough to override those settings, once you know where all the settings are and what you should set them to.

But I'm a bit surprised that it doesn't even have stupid defaults for DVD playback.

Posted by: Pixy Misa at January 15, 2008 11:16 PM (PiXy!)

4

Every other player in the world uses space bar to mean "pause". Even the YouTube flash player does that. Zoomplayer makes the space bar bring up a duplicate copy of the command bar, which is totally useless.

There's a fair amount of "Not Invented Here" going on with this one, too.

Posted by: Steven Den Beste at January 15, 2008 11:54 PM (+rSRq)

5 Hi,
Give The KM Player a chance. I went from VLC to Zoomplayer to the KM Player and it is like, one gazillion times better than the others. Zoomplayer is not bad, but I bet KMPlayer will fix some of your issues. My biggest gripe with Zoomplayer is that it would not let me change ASS subtitle fonts/sizes at all, so it's obvious there's something wrong with the subtitle handling from zoomplayer. The subtitle managemnt in KMPlayer is infinitely better.

Also, Zoomplayer uses FFDshow by default which will do warped resizing (pano-vision or non-linear stretching) of 4:3 content to a WS TV. I believe PowerDVD has that feature too, but only when playing off a real DVD.

Posted by: loppy at January 19, 2008 02:49 AM (wz7Gt)

Hide Comments | Add Comment

Enclose all spoilers in spoiler tags:
      [spoiler]your spoiler here[/spoiler]
Spoilers which are not properly tagged will be ruthlessly deleted on sight.
Also, I hate unsolicited suggestions and advice. (Even when you think you're being funny.)

At Chizumatic, we take pride in being incomplete, incorrect, inconsistent, and unfair. We do all of them deliberately.

How to put links in your comment

Comments are disabled. Post is locked.
13kb generated in CPU 0.056, elapsed 0.0655 seconds.
20 queries taking 0.0568 seconds, 22 records returned.
Powered by Minx 1.1.6c-pink.