August 03, 2008

Zoom Player -- progress report

I've been trying to use Zoom Player for DVDs now in preference to PowerDVD, mostly because continuous experience with it is the only way to really understand its faults and virtues.

And it does have both. Virtues:

* Doing a frame grab grabs the frame that's being displayed. That was the case with earlier versions of PowerDVD, too, but as of the most recent version, you get a grab of the frame several steps later than the one you're looking at.

* When you stop and then do single steps, you have direct control and it acts like you expect it to. In PowerDVD (all versions I've used) your first "step" takes you forward ten or fifteen frames before it finally freezes. Which is a pain.

* When you're using Zoom Player to look at a stored MP4 (e.g. the Strike Witches episodes I've been buying from CrunchyRoll) you can single-step backwards.

* There's more control over jumps. With PowerDVD the PgUp and PgDn buttons respectively jump backwards and forwards by an amount that you can control from a setup page. (I have it set to 10 seconds.) In Zoom Player, currently I'm using the cursor keys for that. Likewise controllable from setup, my "up" key goes ahead 20 seconds, my "right" key goes ahead 5 seconds, my "left" key goes back 5 seconds, and my "down" key goes back 20 seconds. Much handier to readily have more step sizes available.

* One of my biggest bitches with PowerDVD is that the display window size doesn't have anything to do with the native size of the material being displayed, and there's no way to make it have any relationship to that size. Zoom Player has a 100% hotkey (alt 2) and a 200% hotkey (alt 3). When your display size is a reasonable multiple of the native resolution, the display is more crisp. (On the other hand, choosing "100%" doesn't always get you 100%. See below.)

* You can name your bookmarks. Also, you can designate one bookmark per DVD as an auto-start point, which I'm not likely to use much but which I can see as being quite handy as a way of skipping obnoxious logos and advertisements in some cases.

* Frame grabs are named after the disk or file they came from, with a sequence number appended. PowerDVD's frame grabs use a base filename you enter in a setup field, so changing that is a pain.

Faults?

* No graphic thumbnails for bookmarks. In PowerDVD there's a frame you can enter which shows you miniature frame grabs for every bookmark, which is really handy. (Being able to rename bookmarks only somewhat mitigates this.)

* To set a bookmark you have to use a hotkey to bring up a popup, then click a button. There's no direct hotkey for creating a bookmark.

* It has a readout of the native size, but it isn't always right. I watched some of the first season re-release of DBZ last night, which is anamorphic wide screen, and the readout said it was 720*540 (i.e. 4:3) even though it was clearly 16:9.

/images/01872.jpg

(full) The video area is 960*540, even though I set it to "100%". That means it is resized and thus less sharp than it ought to be. It really should be 853*480. (Which is to say, resized in only one dimension, not in both.) And the size readout should be correct.

* Frame grabs are not raw. They're resized to correct the aspect ratio. It looks as if ripping and then using Vidomi on the rip will continue to be my tool-of-choice for getting high quality frame grabs for things like the top rotation.

(Oddly enough, a frame grab of that DBZ DVD shown above is 853*480.)

* Frame grabs include the subtitles if those are turned on. This is something about which I'm highly ambivalent.

* The "single step backward" function (shift-comma) does nothing at all on a DVD. On PowerDVD it steps back by keyframes, which is more coarse than single frames but still useful. (Though the tendency for it to play forward a bunch of frames once you start moving forward again tends to diminish the utility quite a lot.)

* Single-stepping forward (shift-period) makes the sound blurp briefly. I can't see any use for that.

* Setup is a nightmare. Too many choices, not enough explanation, cryptic choices, catastrophic consequences for wrong choices, and no help. Fact is, this program is not ready for prime time because like so many hobbyist-developed packages there's too much concentration on flexibility and not enough concentration on hand-holding for non-cognoscenti users.

Other comments:

Where is it storing the bookmarks? PowerDVD has a function for saving all your bookmarks to a file, which you can transfer to a new computer. In the past I've had trouble making that work, but it did work fine for the most recent version under Vista, so I was able to transfer 2 years of bookmarking onto my new computer. I looked in the Zoom Player home directory, and in all the "usual" places (i.e. in my "user" directory) and couldn't find a ZP-specific file for bookmarks. I'm really afraid they've decided to put them in the registry.

Last night I tried watching the first DVD of the first "Ranma 1/2" series. When it got to the second episode, I thought for a while that Zoom Player had suffered a partial crash. Virtually all of the hotkeys stopped working.

For instance, I couldn't use semi-colon to get to the disk menu. The cursor keys didn't work for doing skips. Also, there was no elapsed-time display bar on the player window. I was afraid something had gotten permanently broken, but it worked fine for the first episode and it worked fine for another DVD I tried, and finally it occurred to me that this is how ZP responds to DVDs which were mastered to shut off some kinds of user functions.

That's part of the DVD specification, and I think that licensed DVD players, software or hardware, are contractually obligated to honor those flags on DVDs. I've always hated that, but I can't blame the makers of player programs since they have no choice. Fortunately, not very many DVDs have those kinds of restrictive settings.

Still, it seems as if ZP has gone rather too far. In PowerDVD I can still get to the DVD menu in those kinds of sections, but the semicolon key in ZP didn't work in that episode, which is how you usually get to the menu.

Now that I have subtitles working, I'm finding that ZP really is a nice alternative to PowerDVD. I'll keep PowerDVD installed on this computer, but I'm beginning to think that ZP will become my standard player. At least no show stoppers yet, now that the subtitle problem has been cleared up.

Posted by: Steven Den Beste in Computers at 01:47 PM | No Comments | Add Comment
Post contains 1150 words, total size 7 kb.

Enclose all spoilers in spoiler tags:
      [spoiler]your spoiler here[/spoiler]
Spoilers which are not properly tagged will be ruthlessly deleted on sight.
Also, I hate unsolicited suggestions and advice. (Even when you think you're being funny.)

At Chizumatic, we take pride in being incomplete, incorrect, inconsistent, and unfair. We do all of them deliberately.

How to put links in your comment

Comments are disabled. Post is locked.
10kb generated in CPU 0.011, elapsed 0.0203 seconds.
18 queries taking 0.0126 seconds, 16 records returned.
Powered by Minx 1.1.6c-pink.