December 17, 2007

Vista: Upgrade available

This post (via) is nicely sarcastic and well handled, but it makes an interesting point: for a lot of people, XP is better than Vista. Microsoft wants to shut XP down, but its customers won't let it. They've already extended the support period for XP once, and I doubt that'll be the last time.

I don't myself regret switching. I could install XP on this machine (and I'm sure I could find drivers for all the things I care about) but I don't really care to do so. Mostly Vista hasn't been a problem.

The seriously degraded backup ability was certainly an unpleasant surprise. Looks like I'll probably have to spend $50 for a third-party solution. (Hooray! Something that isn't from Symantec! Thanks, Bob!)

And there have been pleasant little surprises. One is the fact that fav-ico's no longer show up in my favorites list in IE7. I hate those. HATE HATE HATE those.

They show up in the "current site" bar when I'm browsing, which is fine. But they never show up anymore in shortcut icons anywhere, on the desktop or in folders or in the favorites list. I don't know if that's universal experience. I have a couple of Proxomitron rules which try to prevent access to things named fav.ico, but under XP they'd sometimes slip in anyway.

What I know is that they're no longer bedevilling me.

I know that doesn't sound like a big thing, but in fact most of the differences between XP and Vista in terms of use experience for me have been little things. They're just stuff you have to learn to live with, and most of them can be ameliorated. The others don't happen often enough to really become an annoyance.

The big thing that article mentions as a difference between XP and Vista is a claim that XP feels faster on a particular piece of hardware. I really have no way of testing that. My old notebook has much slower hardware, and XP. The new one has only ever run Vista. But it is fast and responsive, and that article notwithstanding I don't suffer from any 60-second lockups that I've noticed. Whether that's because Vista's speed deficit is being compensated for by triple the CPU power, I couldn't say.

And it must be said, this is really cool:

I don't use it, but it's really cool.

Posted by: Steven Den Beste in Computers at 04:57 PM | Comments (13) | Add Comment
Post contains 398 words, total size 3 kb.

1

I was too lazy to read the whole article, but I wonder if he bought a new machine with Vista or upgraded an existing one.  New MS OSes ALWAYS work better on new hardware.  I have Vista on a homebuilt Core 2 Duo desktop and it runs quite well, and plenty fast--the only issue, and I'm pretty sure it's a mobo issue, not an OS one, is that when I suspend or hibernate the system and restore it later, I lose sound until I reboot.

Also, I have a very nice Dell XPS laptop that came with XP MCE.  I swapped in a new HDD and did a clean Vista install last year, and it's been running Vista perfectly for about 14 mo.  Want Vista to run nicely?  Have new hardware.  I really think there's a strong correlation.  I'm not making any kind of value judgement there, just pointing out my experience.

Posted by: RickC at December 17, 2007 05:43 PM (PoCOp)

2

One of the benefits of buying a pre-built system from a major vendor is that they do everything necessary to make sure the OS and drivers work correctly on the hardware. Perhaps that's one of the reasons I haven't had a lot of the problems he describes.

But that's not unique to Vista. We've had those kinds of problems all the way back to Win 3.1, if not even earlier.

Posted by: Steven Den Beste at December 17, 2007 09:18 PM (+rSRq)

3 My new Vista box is working very well, except for the occasional video glitch.  Either the integrated video is flaky or the drivers are.  I suspect it's the drivers because the video only got glitchy after I installed them.  Before that it worked fine, except that it was verrrry slooow and wouldn't let me run Aero.

That's the only driver I needed to install, though.  Everything else just worked.

On the other hand, when I wiped my Compaq notebook and installed plain XP I had to burn the drivers onto a CD,  because it wouldn't recognise anything.

Posted by: Pixy Misa at December 17, 2007 10:18 PM (PiXy!)

4 Oh, I did manage to lock Vista up for 30 seconds or so by accidentally telling uTorrent to save files straight to my DVD burner.  Oops.  I no longer have a D drive.

The one thing I like most?  The previews on the task bar and the task switcher.  Not just eye candy but genuinely useful.  That and the real support for 64-bit mode.  The handy kill it now! option is also nice.

Posted by: Pixy Misa at December 17, 2007 10:22 PM (PiXy!)

5 It's nice that "kill it now" really does kill it now. It doesn't send a "shut down" signal and wait 30 seconds before giving up and preemptively terminating the task.

Posted by: Steven Den Beste at December 17, 2007 10:28 PM (+rSRq)

6

"It doesn't send a "shut down" signal and wait 30 seconds before giving up and preemptively terminating the task."

Yep, Raymond Chen wrote about that on his blog.  Plenty of applications would catch the "windows wants to shut down now" notification and say no.  This is trouble for people who are using laptops--plenty of people hit the shut down button, stuff the laptop into a bag, and then find out the battery is dead hours later.  Now, Windows gives you the notification but doesn't let you cancel the shutdown.

Blog commenters were resorting to saying "what if you were burning a CD?" to try to find reasons why this change sucked.  Other people said "well, it'd be pretty stupid to do those two things together, wouldn't it?" and "then if I do that, allow the disc to be coastered--media is cheap."

Posted by: RickC at December 18, 2007 05:35 PM (PoCOp)

7
This is trouble for people who are using laptops--plenty of people hit the shut down button, stuff the laptop into a bag, and then find out the battery is dead hours later.
Or that the notebook overheated because it was running for two hours inside the bag...

There was a particular bug if you were running VMWare where XP would go to standby mode - and then restart fifteen seconds later.  They eventually released a hotfix.

Posted by: Pixy Misa at December 18, 2007 06:36 PM (PiXy!)

8

Rick, we're talking about something different.

If you click on an app which isn't responding, or if you try to close it, you get a "Do you want to kill it?" popup. If you say yes, it kills it immediately.

During system shutdown, on the other hand, Vista still gives apps 30 seconds to shut down cleanly. Then, if they are still running, it peremptorily terminates them. XP did the same. That behavior hasn't changed.

People with notebooks who were getting dead batteries were not being hit by that, I'm pretty sure. There are two ways of sleeping without a full shutdown. In the first of those two, the system writes a memory image out to HD and then kills the hardware. In the second, it doesn't write out a memory image, and it only partially kills the hardware. What happens in that case is that the RAM stays running, and continues to draw juice from the battery.

The advantage of the second is that startup is much faster. The disadvantage is that if you leave it like that for 24 hours, your battery will be dead.

I suspect the people you're talking about ran into that feature.

Posted by: Steven Den Beste at December 18, 2007 07:20 PM (+rSRq)

9 Pixy, please read your email. I need some help.

Posted by: Steven Den Beste at December 18, 2007 07:20 PM (+rSRq)

10 Yep, I saw that this morning and tried to reply, but my ISP's email server was down.  I'll get back to you when I get home from work tonight.

Posted by: Pixy Misa at December 18, 2007 07:37 PM (PiXy!)

11 Oh, and sort-of on-topic, there are multiple bugs with the XP standby and hibernate features.  The one I mentioned, where it would go into standby and then wake itself up again.  Another one where it would try to go into standby or hibernate, then come up with a message saying "There are insufficient resources to complete the operation."  Either way, you see the "Windows is preparing to stand by." message, tuck the notebook away in your bag, and come back later to a dead computer.

Posted by: Pixy Misa at December 18, 2007 07:41 PM (PiXy!)

12

"Then, if they are still running, it peremptorily terminates them. XP did the same. That behavior hasn't changed."

Nope, it did NOT terminate processes.  I have one that will pop up a "Windows wants to quit, is this OK?" message box and wait until you answer it, and it WILL prevent Windows from shutting down.  I didn't realize you meant something else--and that thing is cool--but applications could definitely stop a shutdown before Vista.

See http://blogs.msdn.com/oldnewthing/archive/2007/04/16/2148139.aspx and hit the "do it rudely" link.  "When the user asks for the computer to go into a low power state, programs will get notified of the state change but are not allowed to veto it. Programs get two seconds to clean up, and then that's it. The laptop is going into standby, ready or not." 

and http://blogs.msdn.com/mobilepc/archive/2005/09/09/463011.aspx.

Posted by: RickC at December 18, 2007 07:57 PM (PoCOp)

13 Problem with Vista: Somehow my wi-fi internet connection gets shut down somehow after every ten minutes of use. I have to then struggle with all variety of things in the Network Diagnostics app, which seems specifically designed to keep me from ever finding out what the goddamn problem really is. Instead I'm reduced to repeatedly disabling and re-enabling my wireless interface, until something finally clicks and I get another ten minutes of internet access before I lose my connection again.

Problem with XP: My XP install disc doesn't work. They were defective when I got them; the entire i386.cab file on the CD is corrupted, and neither Microsoft nor Best Buy would refund my money or exchange my disc (opened software and all that crap).  I somehow managed to acquire a new i386.cab file online, and copied the whole CD to a partition on my C: drive along with the working i386.cab file, and installed it from there, but I haven't the patience nor the resources to go through that crap again.

Problem with Ubuntu: Tech support is like 4chan, only instead of taking pride in delivering, they take pride in tricking you into nuking your installation in all sorts of creative ways (to my credit, I never fell for the sudo rm -R / trick). After no less than four weeks of careful research, and six reinstallations (seriously, they're sneaky bastards), I finally got my wi-fi working consistently. Now I just need to figure out why my DVD-R drive, keyboard, and touchpad keep spazzing out at apparently random intervals, and I'll be on the Linux bandwagon. At least, until I want to play Half-Life 2 again.

Posted by: Tatterdemalian at December 18, 2007 08:00 PM (j8zCH)

Hide Comments | Add Comment

Enclose all spoilers in spoiler tags:
      [spoiler]your spoiler here[/spoiler]
Spoilers which are not properly tagged will be ruthlessly deleted on sight.
Also, I hate unsolicited suggestions and advice. (Even when you think you're being funny.)

At Chizumatic, we take pride in being incomplete, incorrect, inconsistent, and unfair. We do all of them deliberately.

How to put links in your comment

Comments are disabled. Post is locked.
17kb generated in CPU 0.0126, elapsed 0.0181 seconds.
20 queries taking 0.012 seconds, 30 records returned.
Powered by Minx 1.1.6c-pink.