August 26, 2009
I was curious to see just what the file format on a BD is. Surely they're not using VOB's, so I wondered what they were using. Haven't found that answer yet, but the Wikipedia article about Blu-Ray is interesting, especially the part about DRM.
I remember that one of the key features which Sony (and Toshiba) used to pitch the format to the studios was that the encryption wasn't going to be as paper-thin as the DVD protection turned out to be. Both Blu-Ray and HD-DVD relied on the AACS system, which was very sophisticated and had protection in depth. So there was no risk to the studios to release theater-quality versions of their products on a home format.
Or so it was claimed. According to Wikipedia, "...as of August 2008, all current AACS decryption keys are available on the Internet."
I fully expected that the encryption would fall eventually, but it happened a lot sooner than I thought it would.
Turns out there are a couple of other forms of protection. One is called BD+ and it's interesting. There's a virtual machine in the player, and BD+ is a computer program on the disk which is loaded onto that virtual machine and permitted to run. It can perform sanity checks on the disk and on the player environment, in order to decide if it will permit the disk to play.
Wikipedia says, "The first titles using BD+ were released in October 2007. Versions of BD+ protection have been circumvented by various versions of the AnyDVD HD program." Which I own mwaahaahaa...
It strikes me that this is even more fundamentally insecure than AACS was. If some sort of intermediary (such as AnyDVD HD) gets in the way of reading the BD+ program itself, either indicating that there isn't one, or replacing what's there with a benign "Yeah, unconditionally play it" program, then it's dead meat. No program can save you if the program itself never runs.
A third form of protection (BD-ROM Mark) amounts to a strange way of writing information onto the media, in order to make it so that the media can't be mass-duplicated. It's a special piece of equipment which is used at the foundry. I can see where that would be important to studios, but I'm not interested in doing that.
Anyway, that one is insecure too. It prevents bit-for-bit copies, but who cares about that? If the entire contents of the disk can be read and decrypted, and all DRM removed from it, then that could be written to a new disk with flags set so that BD-ROM isn't needed -- and that could then be mass-duplicated. Different bits, but identical information.
So sounds like the vaunted protection which was one of the features that was going to make this the savior of the studios has already fallen in tatters. It wasn't a house of straw, but it did turn out to be a house of sticks, and the hackers huffed and puffed...
And note that the DMCA didn't prevent it, either.
UPDATE: Looks like SlySoft and the BD people have been playing an arms game regarding the BD+ system. The most recent version showed up in the wild on a BD in February, and SlySoft says they cracked it in a version of AnyDVD HD released in March. Unfortunately, that's since the last time I updated so I may have to update again.
Last time I updated, all my bookmarks in Zoom Player went away. The DVD disk hashes all got read different and Zoom Player got confused about it. So if I have to upgrade AnyDVD HD again, it's going to hurt a bit.
Of course, I still don't even know if there's any point. If I end up using PowerDVD (which will be included with the drive) in order to watch BD's, then AnyDVD HD may be irrelevant.
Meanwhile, NewEgg says that my drive shipped today, so I'll have it on Monday. No word yet from Amazon Japan.
Posted by: Steven Den Beste in Computers at
07:02 PM
| Comments (6)
| Add Comment
Post contains 670 words, total size 4 kb.
Which, given some of the stupidity Sony has been up to lately, I wouldn't put past them. . .
Posted by: metaphysician at August 27, 2009 07:00 AM (M5Kik)
Yeah, I'm surprised that they haven't gone to proprietary formats with firmware coding to contact a network node by a built-in comm device, and verify that the player hasn't been modded and that the DVD (program) playing is approved by the manufactuerer. If it isn't, or if the device has been modded, it shuts itself off -- and the "license" you're forced to accept when you obtain the player makes it all legal.....
Oh, wait, that's called an iPhone. Never mind.
Posted by: ubu at August 27, 2009 07:30 AM (i7ZAU)
Nor is piracy something that Sony cares about enough to pay for using the cell phone network for all those players. It works for the iPhone 'cause it's a cell phone anyway, and the user is paying for it.
(It'd also be very easy to hack such a thing. Just push a firmware update to it that contacted a completely different server. "Hey, is this approved?" "Yeah, yeah, whatever." Or circumvent calling out completely...)
Actually bricking old players would get Sony in massive legal trouble. Lots of states have implied warranties of merchantability, and "your player will work" fits under that just fine.
Posted by: Avatar_exADV at August 27, 2009 07:59 AM (vGfoR)
Posted by: metaphysician at August 27, 2009 11:08 AM (M5Kik)
Really? I thought it interfered with that, so I've avoided DRM-enabled music with a passion. No point in it if I can't load it onto my mp3 player, laptop, computer; wherever and whatever I want to listen to it on.
Lifestyles are too busy to be tied to a single player per purchase, or deal with the hassle of passing something through multiple format changes to get around a largely ineffective scheme.
Posted by: ubu at August 27, 2009 01:53 PM (i7ZAU)
And yeah, burn to CD and re-rip was always a loophole.
Posted by: Pixy Misa at August 27, 2009 05:36 PM (PiXy!)
Enclose all spoilers in spoiler tags:
[spoiler]your spoiler here[/spoiler]
Spoilers which are not properly tagged will be ruthlessly deleted on sight.
Also, I hate unsolicited suggestions and advice. (Even when you think you're being funny.)
At Chizumatic, we take pride in being incomplete, incorrect, inconsistent, and unfair. We do all of them deliberately.
How to put links in your comment
Comments are disabled. Post is locked.20 queries taking 0.0281 seconds, 23 records returned.
Powered by Minx 1.1.6c-pink.